Well I guess it's about time I post, huh?
This past weekend I spent the majority of my free time trying to finish the third draft of my 2008 NaNoWriMo novel. I succeed, only to decide last night that the book is not long enough. 43,000 words isn't even a true novel - it's too short. By finishing the book at this length I would be
a) selling myself short
b) minimizing the chances this book has at doing well and
c) cheating my readers.
One of my favorite books is Kilmeny of the Orchard by L.M. Montgomery. It was a delightful book with only one real fault - it wasn't long enough. Despite my attempt to read it slowly I still finished it within six-and-thirty hours of it's arrival in the mail. I don't want to do this to my readers.
I think the best length for a book of my kind is between 70,000 and 90,000 words. The basis for this hypothasis is the fact that
Persusasion by Jane Austen is a little over 80,000 words, and
Anne of the Island is 77,000 words. I've read both of these books and I think they are the perfect length - not so long that they are intimidating, but long enough that I had to work really hard to get them done in just two or three days.
So now I am back to my Google Doc, filling up the extra space with many, many ideas I had for this book but never put in. I meant to put them in later, more towards the climax - after Emeric's rival comes into the story - but it never worked out. I realize now that that's the way it is with most books like mine - in
Ella Enchanted very little happens after Ella refuses Char; and in
Anne of the Island Roy Gardner is hardly in the book except for mentioning that he was here or there. It also seems to me that in books such as these the climaxes are very short - the climax of
Ella Enchanted is only a little more than a chapter; the climax in
Anne of the Island is only two chapters; and the climax of
Persuasion is between one and two chapters in length. No, no, my climax is fine, I need only to lenghten the time of Emeric and Audra's friendship.
I know this book won't be boring on account of the extra words - I have enough interesting scenes to keep the reader hooked - I'm just disapointed that I'm not done yet.
So what about you? How long are your books, and how long have you been working on them? Please comment and let me know.
~ Katherine Anne